Op-Ed: Parental Advisory

Tuesday, 06 July 2010 11:20 Written by  Essence McDowell

They were a select few were sitting in a room. They crowned themselves as gatekeepers of the nation’s past, and with one vote, history became their-story.


pa

However, none of them were historians, scholars or academics. They were Republicans whose ideas of what should be taught in classrooms were based on biased partisan beliefs.

As a result, the relentless struggle between “left” and “right” has taken over what millions students in grades K-12 will be learning.

The Texas elected state board of education is comprised of 10 Republicans and five Democrats. They have made more than 100 amendments to the social studies, history and economics curriculum since January. The changes will reach deeply into Texas history classrooms, defining what textbooks must include and what teachers must cover.

The last vote in March won with 10 to 5 approval along party lines.  All the Republicans on the board voted for the “right-wing” modifications.

Because the Texas textbook market is so large, books assigned to the state's 4.7 million students often rocket to the top of the market, setting the textbook purchasing trend for districts around the nation.

The curriculum standards were originally proposed by a panel of teachers. However, politicians deeming themselves as “experts” made the final decisions.

Because of 10 Republicans, for the next 10 years students will be taught based on anti-liberal preferences. They have voted to remove current curriculum areas, including civil rights and global politics, replacing them with conservative historic figures and beliefs.

The voting members claimed that they were trying to correct what they see as a liberal bias among the teachers who proposed the curriculum.

One guideline requires publishers to include a section on “the conservative resurgence of the 1980s and 1990s, including Phyllis Schlafly, the Contract with America, the Heritage Foundation, the Moral Majority and the National Rifle Association.”

The curriculum demotes the role of Thomas Jefferson among the founding fathers, because board members' did not approve of his support for separation of church and state.

References to Ralph Nader and Ross Perot are to be removed, while Stonewall Jackson, the Confederate general, is to be listed as a role model for effective leadership, and the ideas in Jefferson Davis’ inaugural address are to be laid side by side with Abraham Lincoln’s speeches.

There is an amendment that deletes a requirement that sociology students, "explain how institutional racism is evident in American society."

Despite the state’s large Hispanic population, the inclusion of Latino figures as role models was denied. An opposed amendment would have integrated the fact that Tejanos Mexicanos died at the Alamo fighting for Texan independence alongside Davie Crockett and Jim Bowie.

According to the changes, “capitalism” is out as a name for the U.S. economic system. One of the members in the Republican majority claimed the term held “negative connotations.” Consequentially, the required term will now be "free enterprise system." This amendment emphasizes the free enterprise system over others as one of the most superior systems in the world.

It was suggested that the curriculum incorporate the study of the impact of cultural movements in art, music and literature such as Tin Pan Alley, the Beat Generation, rock ‘n’ roll, country-western music and hip-hop. The board majority tossed out hip-hop as offensive but made sure to accommodate country music.

As the list of amendments continues, it’s hard to believe that these are actually legitimate changes. Someone would have to be deaf, dumb and blind not to see the narrow-mindedness and political bigotry that these amendments represent.

What the Texas Board of Education has accomplished is building a nation of right-winged thought by squeezing out what they feel is “too liberal” to be taught.

It would have made more common sense if Texas decided to alter curriculums based on the consensus an equal amount of well-educated scientist, researchers, historians and scholars who just so happen to be democrats, republicans and even independents.

Those are people who can be trusted with decisions that will have such crucial consequences for the rest of the country for years to come.

Exclusion is not education. The manipulation of historical figures and events will only lead to increased bias.

Education is the process that has formative effects on the mind, character and ability of our youth.  As these conservatives have their way, they will have a negative impact on the knowledge skills and values of the upcoming generations.

It is not the job of politicians to decide what children will learn. It is the job of scholars and academicians to ensure that students are cultivated into open-minded, enlightened, critical thinking intellectuals.

Unfortunately, when this board has a final vote in May, the outcome will be brainwashed children groomed to fit partisan agendas.

The future of education seems incredibly bleak if Texas’ textbooks other state’s school districts invest in the same books Texas has crafted.

This is not exactly the time for the rest of the nations states to play “follow the leader.”

The fair and factual education of millions of children depends on the ability of parents and politicians around the nation to look past color lines. This time it’s not about black and white, it’s red and blue.

Until then, the textbooks in question should come with Parental Advisory Stickers.

Reader discretion advised. This textbook may contain strong bias. Some readers may find this content offensive that the opinions expressed in these pages do not necessarily reflect the truth.

Don't forget to visit the Glossy Blog!  

Essence McDowell

Essence McDowell

Essence McDowell is a freelance writer for GlossMagazineOnline and recent graduate of the Masters in Journalism program at DePaul University.

She can be contacted at created2write@gmail.com